Feudalism’s Aversion to Education

By S. Arif Hussaini

Voices have been raised mainly by the traditional groups of Pakistani politicians against the recently announced requirement that a person aspiring for a seat in the federal or in a provincial parliament will have to be at least a university graduate to qualify as a candidate. Although the new condition is generally acknowledged as having been laid down not for any ulterior motive of the incumbent rulers but merely to ensure minimum caliber of public representatives, its vehement opposition particularly by the landed aristocracy, underlines the continuing bane of politics being dominated in the country by feudal lords.

Feudalism and education are anathema, indeed, to each other. One derogates the other. Different feudal dynasties control half a dozen political parties, including the two main formations - the Muslim League (N) and the PPP. Ironically enough, the so-called People’s Party is headed by a prominent aristocrat/landlord, Benazir. She talks all the time about elections but has opted to be the chairperson for life of her own party!! That is in keeping with the feudal spirit.

The end of the British rule in South Asia also marked the beginning of the end of feudalism - the British system of indirect control - in all countries of the region with the glaring exception of Pakistan. Education has perhaps been the biggest casualty of this act of omission. The exigencies of the early years of the new state, allowed the establishment to put on hold land reforms. The feudal elite, with the connivance of civil and military bureaucracies, managed to establish their hold on the country’s politics and for decades to come. The rapacious rural aristocracy became the biggest force for the maintenance of the status quo in politics and policy making. No wonder the first general elections could not be held before 1970 - 23 years after the creation of Pakistan. The feudal lords of West Pakistan, masquerading as socialists under Bhutto’s People’s Party, refused to hand over power to a commoner from the Eastern wing despite the fact that the latter had won an overwhelming majority in the parliament. Bhutto was their leader then and his daughter, Benazir, heads the coterie now. Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan, a blue-blooded landlord, is holding the fort for her as she is unwilling to return to her country to face the corruption charges against her in courts of law.

During the entire history of the country, education has remained sadly neglected. Educational reforms, whenever carried out, like those of President Ayub or of Prime Minister Z.A. Bhutto, touched the issues only superficially without developing a questioning mind among the youth of the country to challenge the feudal domination. The result of such a criminal neglect of the educational sector is that today nearly a third of 5-9 year olds are out of school and literacy rate is 38 per cent only. Allocations for education have lingered for years around 2.3 per cent of GNP per annum as against a minimum of 4 per cent recommended by the UN. Here in the US, highest priority is given to education.

Readers of this column would recall that the single most significant factor in their ability to reach this country, has been their education back home. Reverting to the situation in Pakistan, one finds that now the students who opt for science subjects fail to apply a scientific approach to their subject, as the educational system stifles their imagination, creativity and curiosity. It is the spirit of inquiry which makes a nation, and its absence mars it and relegates it to the dustbin of history. Pakistan is producing now only 40 Ph.Ds. annually as against 5,000 by India! Education is not, lamentably, considered crucial, the very life-blood for the society’s survival and progress. The generation which came to Pakistan from India carrying with them a high value for education has gradually faded out and their children too have absorbed the feudalistic spirit of getting something for nothing. Or, they have managed to leave the country for foreign lands where they could labor and live well, unhindered and unsuppressed by the ruling elite. The unskilled, semi-skilled workers too managed during 1975-90 to reach the Middle East to earn respectable wages. Their remittances enabled their families to send their children to schools. But, the rapacious politicians and their corrupt bureaucratic minions had, meanwhile, set up a system of ghost schools to misappropriate government funds. Ten per cent of some 42,000 schools in Sindh, for instance, had become schools on paper only. The percentage in Punjab was no better. The children of the workers in the Middle East, particularly those hailing from remote villages, had acquired the means to go to schools but there were no schools within easy reach. So they went to the religious schools attached to local mosques where they could hardly get the education that would enable them to eke out a living. The supremacy of the landlord remained undisturbed. The opportunity went to waste. In this depressing scenario, the projects launched by the present government hold out a ray of hope of change in the obnoxious system. Expansion of educational facilities from elementary school to post-graduate levels, registration of religious schools, introducing secular subjects in their syllabi and enabling them financially to hire teachers for the new subjects, expansion of higher level education in science and technology in concert with other Muslim countries, are some of the salient feature. But, the most important factor is the change in the value system and the mind-set concerning education. The negative and hypocritical approach of the landed aristocracy will have to yield place to genuine appreciation and effort to spread education in the country. That can come only when the elected representatives are themselves educated. Some Pakistani newspapers have published lists of prominent landlords who are non-graduates. Some have not even crossed high school level. Being thus sidelined would hopefully awaken them to the reality that the days of inheriting power and pelf by birth have come to an end. If they do not see the writing on the wall, the wind of change will sweep them down into dust.

Date/Time Last Modified: 3/29/2003 9:29:13 AM

© 2004, Human Development Foundation. All rights reserved.
1350 Remington Road, Suite W, Schaumburg, Il. 60173
Toll Free: (800) 705-1310 | Email: info@yespakistan.com | Privacy Policy