|
Pakistan's
paradox: weak institutions but strong people
By YesPakistan.com Staff
Writer
Pakistan's economy, you
may be surprised to know, improved drastically in a period of over 20 years.
But sadly, this has not been reflected in improving the lot of the average Pakistani.
Overall, Pakistan's real
income per capita increased by a whopping 231 percent between 1970 and 1993.
This was the highest rate of increase in all of South Asia. But sadly, the country's
progress on the plane of human development at the same time did not correspond
to this boom.
Such is the paradox of Pakistan,
a country which has one of the lowest literacy rates in the world, but, interestingly,
some of its highly educated people have dominated many international forums.
In addition, Pakistan's human capital abroad represents some of the finest talent
available, not to mention millions of dollars of investment.
There are few countries
in the world which show a larger gap between their performance on economic growth
and human development than does Pakistan. The discrepancy is even more obvious
when compared to the performance of other countries.
For example, in economic
terms, Pakistan's real per capita income (in PPP dollars) is about 75 percent
higher than India's. Yet it lags behind India in adult literacy and most other
social indicators.
This comparison is even
more disturbing when made with Sri Lanka, which is comparable to Pakistan in
terms of per capital income.
Pakistan's adult literacy
rate is 36 percent, compared to 90 percent in Sri Lanka. The country's average
life expectancy is ten years lower than Sri Lanka's. Pakistan is 45 ranks lower
than Sri Lanka on the Human Development Index (according to the rankings in
the Human Development Report 1996), despite the fact that the difference in
their per capita income ranks is only 22.
To put it simply, the difference
between Pakistan and Sri Lanka's human development ranks is twice as high as
the difference in their ranks. This indicates how poorly Pakistan has translated
its income into an improvement in the lives of its people.
There are a number of reasons
for this discrepancy between economic growth and human development in Pakistan.
Some of these include: an extremely skewed income distribution; no significant
land reforms; the heavy burden of defense and debt servicing on small budgetary
resources; a very corrupt ruling elite, just to name a few.
Another major dilemma the
country faces is the steady deterioration in its institutions. There is still
a problem establishing public accountability. Although Pakistan inherited a
strong civil service, it is now not only very politicized, but also demoralized.
Over 90 percent of recruitment in government service and corporations is based
on provincial domicile, not merit.
And in the midst of this
discrepancy, the common Pakistani struggles to improve his or her lot in life.
While some do succeed in breaking out of the cycle of poverty, they are very
few. For the average Pakistani, who is ambitious, honest and hardworking, there
seems to be little hope to relieve him or herself from the daily struggle against
deprivation in terms of basic needs and education especially.
Pakistan is clearly a country
of weak institutions. But on a positive note, it is made up of strong individuals.
This lack of advancement
in the area of human development is why organizations like the Human Development
Foundation and others are needed to fill in the gap. Since the country's institutions
are so weak, despite the presence of strong individuals seeking advancement
and self-reliance, the majority of Pakistanis remain poor and illiterate.
Capitalizing on Pakistan's
strength, which is its self-reliant and ambitious people, HDF has successfully
improved the lot of thousands of Pakistanis through its projects in every province
of Pakistan. Whether it's through the micro-credit program, which offers easily
accessible and interest-free loans to hard working and honest individuals who
are usually turned down by the country's financial institutions, or its schools,
which use the talents and skills of local teachers combined with the thirst
for knowledge found in young and poorer Pakistanis to provide basic education
to an ignored segment of the population.
All of these programs aim
at empowering Pakistan's strong individuals, who must not remain in the abyss
of poverty and illiteracy due to weak institutions and the government's often
misguided priorities.
It is high time that Pakistan's
leadership make a concerted effort to use the country's enormous economic potential
to give a much needed boost to the country's human development. This must be
done on a large scale, since efforts of groups like HDF are a virtual drop in
the bucket of poverty and illiteracy.
Date/Time Last Modified: 6/18/2002 8:06:37 AM
© 2004, Human Development
Foundation. All rights reserved.
1350 Remington Road, Suite W, Schaumburg, Il. 60173
Toll Free: (800) 705-1310 | Email: info@yespakistan.com
| Privacy Policy
|